Subjectivity as a problem of translatability gabriel pareyon department of musicology university of helsinki the concept of aristotelian purity, concerning the objectivesubjective debate, has been broadly treated from a plethora of perspectives. Roman ingarden, vom erkennen des literarisehen kunstwerks tubingen, 19681, pp. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. The aesthetics of roman ingarden philosophy and phenomenological. Simultaneously, his ontology and aesthetics inspire a large body of philosophical and detailed studies of culture. Roman ingardens unique conception of aesthetic objects. He initially studied mathematics and philosophy in lwow now known as lviv and in ukraine, and in 1912 went to gottingen where he studied philosophy under edmund husserl, taking four semesters of seminars with husserl, from 1912 to 1914, and again during the summer of 1915. Ingarden oli filosofinen realisti ja fenomenologi, mutta han ei kuitenkaan hyvaksynyt edmund husserlin transsendentaalista idealismia. Vom formalen aufbau des individuaellen gegenstandes 1935, the formal ontology of an autonomous individual object. Even a very ambitious attempt at investigating roman ingardens academic work 1 does not include his work in the field of philosophy of culture. Roman ingarden and the realismidealism debate ontology. In the collection of articles entitled roman ingarden and contemporary polish aesthetics, 1 various polish aestheticians and theoreticians of the individual arts have presented their views concerning the impact which ingardens aesthetical thought has had in polish philosophical circles.
Roman witold ingarden was born on february 5, 1893 in krakow. The philosopher discussed more specific ontological questions in his other works. Pokus charakteristiky filozofickej osobnosti a diela. Northwestern university press, 1973 literary criticism 415 pages. Roman witold ingarden was a polish philosopher who worked in phenomenology, ontology. The aim of the present paper is to eliminate a seeming redundancy in roman ingardens theory of perceptual intentionality and, through this, provide a modest and partial defense of his theory. Jahrhunderts publizieren sie ihre hausarbeiten, referate, essays, bachelorarbeit oder masterarbeit. The reception in polish literature of roman ingardens theory.
Bachelorarbeit, masterarbeit, hausarbeit oder dissertation. Pdf roman ingardens problems with avantgarde music michal. Though it is interdisciplinary in scope, situated as it is on the borderlines of ontology and logic, philosophy of literature and theory of language, ingarden s work has a deliberately narrow focus. Vom erkennen des literarischen kunstwerks, tubingen. Roman ingarden 1893 1970 was a polish phenomenologist, ontologist and aesthetician.
Pokus charakteristiky filosoficke osobnosti a dila. Roman ingardens theory of the musical work is usually criticized for not being able to handle the problems of. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. February 5, 1893 june 14, 1970 was a polish philosopher who worked in phenomenology, ontology and aesthetics before world war ii, ingarden published his works mainly in the german language. A student of edmund husserls from the gottingen period, ingarden was a realist phenomenologist who spent much of his career working against what he took to be husserls turn to transcendental idealism. Jahrhunderts publizieren sie ihre hausarbeiten, referate. Roman ingardens philosophy of culture springerlink.